Five students at Bayview High sit in a classroom for detention one afternoon. Before the day is over, one of them is dead–and the other four are being treated as murder suspects. Although the four teens don’t have much in common, they find that there are plenty of secrets to go around–and one of them might be pretty guilty.
Karen McManus’ debut novel is a fast-paced, twisty surprise of a book. The beginning might feel like a modern-day rehash of The Breakfast Club, but the plot quickly turns that on its head and presents readers with something completely different, and the result is a ton of fun. Fairly distinct characters (though not always distinct in their narrative voices) and mostly believable dialogue as well as a romance that feels authentic makes this a crowd-pleaser for even the pickiest of teens.
Super-savvy mystery readers might figure out at least part of the mystery before it fully unfolds, but there are still twists and turns that will surprise. There’s a surprising amount of depth to each of the characters, turning this novel into something a bit more substantial than what it looks like on the surface. I devoured this in a single night, and it was well worth the lost sleep.
Take one part Pretty Little Liars, one part John Hughes, and a little inventiveness on the part of McManus, and you’ve got this book. It’s compulsively readable, and teens (and adults) won’t be able to put it down until they’re finished. McManus is an author to watch. Recommended.
One of Us is Lying by Karen McManus. Delacorte: 2017. Library copy.